EIA files comments on the FTC’s Proposed Enforcement Policy Statement on Personalized Pricing, with a clear ask: target hidden premiums, not the welcome offers, loyalty rewards, and coupon codes consumers love.
On September 24th, the Ecommerce Innovation Alliance (EIA) filed formal comments with the Federal Trade Commission on its Proposed Enforcement Policy Statement Regarding Personalized Pricing (Docket No. FTC-2026-1057). You can read our full comments.
Let’s start with where we agree with the Commission. Consumers should never be charged a secret, data-driven premium above the price everyone else sees. Hidden fees, fake reference prices, and bait-and-switch tactics hurt shoppers and hurt the honest businesses that compete against them. EIA supports vigorous enforcement against all of it.
The problem is that the Proposed Statement, as written, does not stop there. Its definition of “personalized pricing” is broad enough to reach the most ordinary tools in ecommerce: the 15 percent welcome offer for a new email subscriber, the loyalty reward for a repeat customer, the abandoned-cart reminder, the birthday discount, and subscribe-and-save pricing. Under the proposal, a merchant using those tools could be expected to disclose, offer by offer, what customer data shaped each one. For a five-person company, that is not a disclosure requirement. It is a reason to stop offering discounts altogether.
Who we are, and why we weighed in
EIA represents more than 20,000 members across all fifty states. Most are small and mid-sized businesses: clothing and apparel labels, jewelry and accessories brands, cosmetics lines, home-goods stores, family farms selling direct to consumers, and the technology providers that serve them. They are not the big-box retailers and national chains whose practices fill the Proposed Statement’s examples. But they are the businesses that would feel its effects most, because they have no compliance department, no in-house counsel, and no data-science team to build a disclosure engine.
What we told the FTC
Our comments make a few core points.
- Discounts are pro-consumer. Personalized offers in ecommerce are overwhelmingly about giving customers a lower price, not a higher one. They deliver the right deal to the right shopper and cut down on the blast emails and junk coupons that nobody wants.
- The timing could not be worse for household budgets. Consumers are still feeling years of elevated prices, and more of them are turning to coupons and discount codes to stretch a paycheck. A policy that chills everyday discounting would raise the prices people actually pay, and it would hit the most price-sensitive households hardest.
- Compliance would be close to impossible for small businesses. Most small merchants run their promotions through third-party platforms they do not control, and their offers change constantly. Cataloging and disclosing the logic behind every one of them is not realistic.
- The litigation risk is real. Thirty states and the District of Columbia direct their courts to follow the FTC’s interpretations of the FTC Act. A vague federal standard would become a template for demand letters and lawsuits under state consumer-protection laws, and small businesses are the easiest targets.
- A decision this big deserves a full record. The Commission is making broad policy through an enforcement policy statement, on a record that says almost nothing about small and mid-sized businesses. When early staff findings from the FTC’s surveillance pricing study were released in January 2025, then-Commissioner, now-Chairman Andrew Ferguson dissented, stressing the value of rigorous, completed Section 6(b) studies. That principle applies with full force here.
- There has never been a right to a uniform price. Selective discounting, from the merchant who knows her regulars to the Sunday circular, is as old as American commerce. The single fixed price tag is the relatively recent invention.
- The lines the proposal draws are unprincipled. Forcing merchants to publish the recipe behind their discounts is an instruction manual for gaming them. And sparing industries that have “traditionally” priced without disclosure, such as car dealerships, while burdening new and transparent online businesses gets the policy exactly backwards.
In our members’ own words
The heart of our filing is the voices of the merchants themselves. We surveyed our network and included their responses, with their permission, in the comments.
“My concern is that these are not sophisticated pricing algorithms designed to determine how much a particular individual is willing to pay. They are standard ecommerce tools that small businesses use every day to welcome a new customer, recover an abandoned cart, reconnect with a previous customer, reward loyalty, or make repeat purchasing easier.”
– Founder, 3 Moms Organics (East Hampton, New York)
“This implementation would shut my rural agricultural business down. . . . I don’t have the financial bandwidth to hire another person nor pay another company to manage this type of process.”
– A fifth-generation family farm in Iowa
“Customized discounts and incentives are a crucial way in which we can recognize and celebrate frequent customers. . . . These discounts work the same and allow us to replicate that same kind of feeling with customers.”
– Carly Redford, Armada, Inc. (Massachusetts)
“It isn’t a lever for finding out what someone will pay or personalized pricing; everyone is eligible. It’s what turns ‘I’ve been curious about that for years’ into an order.”
– Justin Allen, CEO, Tushy
Klaviyo, whose email, SMS, and loyalty tools are used by thousands of ecommerce businesses, warned that if the FTC does not clearly separate ordinary personalization from personalized pricing, “platforms will have to design for the broadest possible interpretation,” and merchants “will lose access to tools that support lawful discounts, loyalty programs, segmentation, cart-abandonment offers, and other targeted benefits.”
Alex Beller, Co-CEO of Postscript and a member of EIA’s Board, reminded the Commission that every text a brand sends through Postscript goes to a shopper who “affirmatively signed up to receive it,” and that a birthday discount or cart reminder “is not surveillance. It is the relationship she chose.” If the rules are unclear, he warned, brands “will simply stop sending discounts, and the shoppers who count on those savings will be the ones who lose.”
We also heard from a Cincinnati chocolate maker, a California organic food brand, a second Iowa small business, and others. Their message was the same: these tools are how small brands compete with the largest retailers on earth, and customers understand and seek them out.
What we asked the FTC to do
EIA offered six recommendations:
- Limit the policy to situations where a consumer is charged more than the normal advertised price, and make clear it does not reach discounts and promotions.
- Confirm a clear path to compliance for offers based on a merchant’s own first-party relationship with its customers.
- If broader action is warranted, build a real record first, including the experience of small and mid-sized businesses, before finalizing anything.
- Apply any principles neutrally across business models, rather than favoring “traditional” industries.
- Place any disclosure obligation on the party that actually sets the price, not on the technology vendors that supply configurable tools.
- At a minimum, exempt small and mid-sized businesses from any disclosure obligation through a revenue threshold or the SBA’s existing size standards.
We are not alone
Voices from across the policy spectrum have drawn the same lines. In this docket, the Mercatus Center, Independent Women, and the Center for AI and Digital Policy each raised concerns that echo ours. And even the American Economic Liberties Project, a leading advocate for action against surveillance pricing, told Congress this summer that sound legislation should not prohibit senior, student, or veterans’ discounts and should allow loyalty programs. When groups that rarely agree on much point to the same distinction, the Commission should take notice.
Thank you, and what comes next
Thank you to every EIA member who took the time to share their experience, and to our partners who helped sharpen these comments. Your stories made this filing far stronger than anything we could have written alone.
This is not the end of the process. EIA will keep engaging with the Commission, share updates as the docket develops, and continue collecting member experiences to add to the record. If your business relies on welcome offers, loyalty programs, or other everyday promotions and you want to share how this proposal would affect you, please reach out to us.
A coupon is not a con. We hope the Commission agrees.
Join the EIA today to help strengthen and shape policies that affect all ecommerce businesses. Together, we can continue to create the future of ecommerce. Subscribe to EIA email updates to stay informed on key developments and their impact on your business.
Ecommerce Innovation Alliance provides members with analysis of litigation and regulatory developments affecting online commerce and digital marketing. This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Members with questions about their specific practices should consult counsel.